25 January 2011
Alcalay
RN, Siderowf A, Ottman R, Caccappolo E, Mejia-Santana H, Tang MX, Rosado L,
Louis E, Ruiz D, Waters C, Fahn S, Cote L, Frucht S, Ford B, Orbe-Reilly M, Ross
B, Verbitsky M, Kisselev S, Comella C, Colcher A, Jennings D, Nance M, Bressman
S, Scott WK, Tanner C, Mickel S, Rezak M, Novak KE, Friedman JH, Pfeiffer R,
Marsh L, Hiner B, Clark LN, Marder K
Background: While Parkinson disease (PD) is consistently associated with impaired olfaction, one study reported better olfaction among
Parkin mutation carriers than noncarriers. Whether olfaction differs between Parkin mutation heterozygotes and carriers of 2 Parkin mutations (compound heterozygotes) is unknown.
Objective: To assess the relationship between Parkin genotype and olfaction in PD probands and their unaffected relatives.
Methods: We administered the University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test (UPSIT) to 44 probands in the Consortium on Risk
for Early-Onset Parkinson Disease study with PD onset ≤50 years (10 Parkin
mutation heterozygotes, 9 compound heterozygotes, 25 noncarriers) and
80 of their family members (18 heterozygotes, 2 compound
heterozygotes, 60 noncarriers). In the probands,
linear regression was used to assess the association between UPSIT
score
(outcome) and Parkin genotype
(predictor), adjusting for covariates. Among family members without PD,
we compared UPSIT performance in heterozygotes
vs noncarriers using generalized estimating
equations, adjusting for family membership, age, gender, and smoking.
Results: Among probands with PD, compound heterozygotes had higher UPSIT scores (31.9) than heterozygotes (20.1) or noncarriers (19.9)
(p < 0.001). These differences
persisted after adjustment for age, gender, disease duration, and
smoking. Among relatives without
PD, UPSIT performance was similar in
heterozygotes (32.5) vs noncarriers (32.4), and better than in
heterozygotes with PD
(p = 0.001).
Conclusion: Olfaction is significantly reduced among Parkin
mutation heterozygotes with PD but not among their heterozygous
relatives without PD. Compound heterozygotes with PD have
olfaction within the normal range. Further
research is required to assess whether these findings reflect different
neuropathology
in Parkin mutation heterozygotes and compound heterozygotes.